You are here: Home In the Organic Garden Problem solving How safe are railway sleepers?

Print E-mail
railway sleepers
Railway sleepers

There are al ot of conflicting reports about how railway sleepers should be used.

The Pesticide Control Service (PCS), have placed seizure orders on shipments of railway sleepers coming into the country. The reason for this is that the sleepers have been soaked in creosote. Creosote was banned in 2003 because of a risk of cancer and the EU concluded that even low levels of the substance cause rashes and irritations. The sleepers that are now sitting in the garden centres and DIY stores can only be sold to farmers.

Sleepers do ooze creosote in hot weather and there are over 200 chemicals in creosote. Another worry is that if you have raised beds made from them, the chemicals could seep into the soil and be absorbed by the plants. A spokesperson for the Environmental Protection Agency claims that the “sleepers were being used for improper purposes, in domestic situations where there was a risk of contact with creosote”

Never mind! There are plenty of other things to make raised beds out of (I made a great one out of old books once –maybe not as aesthetically pleasing, but it did the job).

If you have any questions about the issue, hopefully these forum links will help you decide what to do.  In these pages you will find further links to environmental agancies:

BBC

Gardenplans ireland

Gardening.co.uk

Boards.ie

 

Trackback(0)
Comments (1)Add Comment
0
Bit more
written by Turf and stuff.com, August 26, 2010
Used railway sleepers

These are the best sleepers for your garden if you are looking for rustic character. Our reclaimed sleepers are all hardwood, most often oak. They will last a very long time and with no further treatment.

However, there are some very important considerations about where you should use reclaimed railway sleepers

The problems arise with what treatments the railway sleepers have had in the past. They have all had a creosote treatment (sometimes repeat treatments) in their life. Creosote is now frowned upon as it is a carcinogen. This is one of the European belt and braces recommendations. The risk is there but is very low.

The implications of this is that these sleepers can be used, but not inside and not anywhere where frequent skin contact will be made. The creosote is sometimes applied in a tar mix. This can also sometimes seep out of the sleepers in hot weather.

It is absolutely fine to use reclaimed sleepers to create paths, steps, raised borders, bridges and retaining walls.

If you are creating a children’s play area or sandpit, then you must use the new railway sleepers. They have been pressure treated with a non-toxic treatment that will let them last for a very long time (up to 25 years). They are made of softwood and so are much easier to carry, handle and cut. They are however not as strong as used sleepers so are not as suitable for heavy load bridges.

The Tannilith used to treat these sleepers has a green colour, but we sometimes have ones that have had a brown dye added. Over time both these colours will fade to a lighter pine colour. You can paint or stain the new railway sleepers to any colour that you want.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 

forum advert

Log in - Register

BBC Gardeners' World - Blog

QUESTION TIME

How do you feel about allotments?
 

Follow us....

Creative Commons License
Gardening Ireland by gardening.ie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.